Congenital Cardiac Surgery Curriculum

3 Programme of Learning

This section covers the expected learning outcomes, learning methods, breadth of experience and levels of performance at critical progression points in the training programme and the levels of performance expected of those completing training.

The practice of Congenital Cardiac Surgery requires the generic and specialty knowledge, clinical and technical skills and behaviours to manage patients presenting with the full range of acute and elective congenital cardiac surgical conditions. It involves development of competence in diagnostic reasoning, managing uncertainty, dealing with co-morbidities, and recognising when another specialty opinion or care is required (as well as developing technical skills in the areas and to the level described in the syllabus as shown in appendix 2). The main areas for learning are described by the CiPs which are the high-level learning outcomes for training in Congenital Cardiac Surgery described below and shown in full in appendix 1.

Training is designed to produce a person capable of safely and effectively performing the role of a first day consultant surgeon. The role of a consultant surgeon can be thought of as a sum of all the various tasks which need to be performed through a working week. These tasks are the high-level outcomes of the curriculum and grouping these together describe the role of a consultant surgeon. To perform a high level clinical task as a consultant surgeon requires trainees to be able to integrate areas of learning from all parts of the syllabus, including knowledge, clinical skills, professional skills and technical skills. In addition, a surgeon will need to have acquired the generic skills, behaviours and values shared by all doctors in order to perform this task safely and well. A capability is a set of skills that can be developed through training from novice to expert and, therefore these high-level clinical outcomes are known as Capabilities in Practice. They are common across all surgical specialties and are delivered within the context of the GPCs and the specialty syllabus.

There are five CiPs which are shared between all surgical specialties:

  1. Manages an outpatient clinic
  2. Manages the unselected emergency take
  3. Manages ward rounds and the on-going care of in-patients
  4. Manages an operating list
  5. Manages multi-disciplinary working
  6. Manages patients within the critical care area*
  7. Assesses surgical outcomes both at a personal and unit level*

*In addition to these, the specialty-specific Cardiothoracic Surgery (parent specialty) CiPs

The generic knowledge, skills, behaviours and values shared by all doctors are described in the GPC framework. The GPCs are essential components and have equal weight to the CiPs in the training and assessment of clinical capabilities and responsibilities in the training programme.

The GPC framework has nine domains:

Domain 1: Professional values and behaviours

Domain 2: Professional skills

Practical skills
Communication and interpersonal skills
Dealing with complexity and uncertainty
Clinical skills

Domain 3: Professional knowledge

Professional requirements
National legislative requirements
The health service and healthcare system in the four countries

Domain 4: Capabilities in health promotion and illness prevention

Domain 5: Capabilities in leadership and team working

Domain 6: Capabilities in patient safety and quality improvement

Patient safety
Quality improvement

Domain 7: Capabilities in safeguarding vulnerable groups

Domain 8: Capabilities in education and training

Domain 9: Capabilities in research and scholarship

Simply put, the CiPs and GPCs are the constituent parts of the role of a consultant congenital cardiac surgeon. Each part is as important as the next and doctors are required to be capable in all parts of the role in order to be able to practice independently. In order to complete training and be recommended to the GMC for certification and entry to the specialist register, the doctor must demonstrate that they are capable of unsupervised practice in all the CiPs and GPCs. For example, managing the unselected emergency take (CiP 2) requires the integration of knowledge, clinical and diagnostic skills, and technical skills described in the syllabus as well as communication and interpersonal skills, time management skills and many other generic skills described in the GPCs in order to be delivered safely, professionally and effectively. This will be assessed using the Multiple Consultant Report (MCR) as described below. The full content of the seven CiPs can be found in appendix 1.

The Interrelationship between GPCs, CiPs and MCRS

Figure 2 - The interrelationship of the GPCs, the syllabus, the CiPs and their descriptors to the role of a consultant surgeon. Items from the syllabus are combined with items taken from the GPC framework to form the small tasks which are the CiP descriptors. When the small tasks of the descriptors are integrated they comprise the constituent parts of the role of a consultant surgeon (the CiPs). When the CiPs are taken together, along with the GPCs, the role of a consultant surgeon (the overall outcome of the curriculum), is described. Each of these CiPs will be developed through training until the level required of a day-one consultant is reached. Assessment in an outcomes-based curriculum through the MCR examines the trainee from the perspective of the outcome (a consultant surgeon), and compares performance in each CiP and in the GPCs to that level. If the outcome level is not reached, then targeted feedback and development plans can be made with reference to the CiP descriptors and beyond to the syllabus items and GPC items that combine to form the descriptors.

The seven CiPs taken together describe the role of a consultant congenital cardiac surgeon but more detail is needed to help trainees develop that capability through training via detailed feedback and focused development goals.

We can break the CiPs down into smaller tasks. Each of these smaller tasks is a CiP descriptor. For example, managing the unselected emergency take (CiP 2), includes the need to promptly assess acutely unwell and deteriorating patients and deliver resuscitative treatment and initial management and ensure sepsis is recognised and treated in compliance with protocol (see appendix 1). If a trainee has not yet reached the level required of a new consultant in a CiP then the descriptors can be used to describe in standard language what needs to be improved through learning and training to allow the trainee to get closer towards the outcome of training. By describing the component parts of a CiP, descriptors also aid decisions on assessment of the level of supervision required by a trainee at the time of that assessment, providing prompts for feedback of performance by allowing identification of areas of excellence or specific detail on areas for development, including in behavioural and professional domains. Descriptors can, therefore, help trainees identify where to focus their efforts to become competent and safe independent practitioners. More detail about assessment and feedback is given in section 5, Programme of Assessment.

Each CiP is judged against a scale that describes the level of supervision required to perform the CiP to the standard of certification. The level of supervision changes in line with the trainee’s progression, consistent with safe and effective care for the patient. Typically, there should be a gradual reduction in the level of supervision required and an increase in the complexity of cases managed until the level of competence for independent practice is acquired. In the early years, therefore, it would be normal for trainees to achieve a lower supervision level and progress as experience is gained.

The supervision levels are:

Level I: Able to observe only

Level II: Able and trusted to act with direct supervision:

a) Supervisor present throughout
b) Supervisor present for part

Level III: Able and trusted to act with indirect supervision

Level IV: Able and trusted to act at the level expected of a day-one consultant

Level V: Able and trusted to act at a level beyond that expected of a day-one consultant

A trainee becomes eligible for certification when supervison level IV has been achieved in both the shared and specialty-specific CiPs in the sub-specialty as well as acquiring all of the skills described in the GPC framework (and the other certification requirements shown in section 5.4) as confirmed by an ARCP panel.

Excellence will be recognised by:

a) Achievement of Level V in any of the CiPs
b) Exceeding the supervision level expected for the end of phase 3
c) Achievement of a supervision level at an earlier stage than would normally be expected
d) Recognition of particularly good performance in any of the descriptors within a CiP.

Capability in practice (shared) Supervision Level
(end of phase 3 and certification)
Manages an out-patient clinic Level IV
Manages the unselected emergency take Level IV
Manages ward rounds and the on-going care of in-patients Level IV
Manages an operating list Level IV
Manages multi-disciplinary working Level IV

Specialty-specific CiPs

Table 1: Supervision levels to be achieved by the end of training
Capability in practice (specialty-specific) Supervision level (end of phase 3 and certification)
6. Manages patients within the critical care area Level IV
7. Assesses surgical outcomes both at a personal and unit level Level IV

The curriculum requires trainees to accrue a rich experience that promotes deep learning of knowledge, clinical skills, technical skills, professional behaviour, leadership and all other generic professional skills that are considered necessary to ensure patient safety throughout the training process and specifically at the end of training. The scope of practice of a day-one consultant is described in the syllabus.

3.5.1 The syllabus

The syllabus, shown in appendix 2, provides a detailed description of the specialty-specific knowledge, clinical and technical skills required for the sub-specialty phase of training and for certification in Cardiothoracic Surgery and the sub-specialty of Congenital Cardiac Surgery. The syllabus is organised by topics which are the presenting conditions of patients in relation to the sub-specialty. Trainees are expected to have exposure to all topics in phase 3 of training.